| Re: Taylor: Reactions (Origins 16:8-9) | Taylor, RE; Brown, RH. 1989.
Origins-GRI 16(1):8-10. CELD ID 2731Abstract Dr. R.H. Brown noted reports by AMS (accelerator [or atomic] mass spectrometry) laboratories of measurable 14C activity in samples such as anthracite coal. His statement that such results were "unexpected" suggests that he perhaps does not fully understand the history and nature of low-level 14C counting technology and therefore may have misunderstood the major point of these reports. In an earlier draft of this response, I had provided a brief explanation of the basic principles of 14C counting instrumentation and how the development of AMS technology relates to conventional approaches. However, the editor has requested a much-shortened comment. For those interested in a more complete explanation, there is a large literature, a small portion of which has been listed in the bibliography of a recent volume on radiocarbon dating (1) which was reviewed by Dr. Brown in a previous issue of ORIGINS.
|